MCPEmails alternative for inboxes that need cleaning
MCPEmails is a well-built hosted email MCP server with a documented safety model. Connect My Email covers the same ground and adds the part MCPEmails leaves out: a classifier that decides what to offer for cleanup, and sweeps that cover a whole mailbox. Facts about MCPEmails below were read from mcpemails.com on 2026-10-09.
MCPEmails
A hosted MCP server that gives an AI agent an inbox. Gmail, Outlook and Microsoft 365, Fastmail, iCloud, Yahoo, Zoho, Yandex and any IMAP account. 17 documented tools, a server-enforced send approval hold, idempotency keys, and scheduled automations that never delete mail. Open source under AGPL, with a self-host option. Their safety model.
Connect My Email
A hosted MCP server for the inbox you already use. Gmail (Google verification pending) and Outlook over OAuth, iCloud, Yahoo, Fastmail and any IMAP account. 150+ tools, a classifier in front of every bulk cleanup that keeps 11 kinds of mail by default, scans of up to 500,000 messages, and a $19 one-time Sweep. Everything that deletes moves to Trash. How CME keeps you safe.
What MCPEmails does well
- Send approval is enforced on the server. A workspace owner or admin can hold outbound mail for review before it leaves. The hold is not a prompt to the model; it is a server state.
- Idempotency keys everywhere a send happens. Sends, replies, forwards, draft sends and scheduled sends each accept a key that makes a retry safe for 24 hours. A reuse with different arguments is rejected.
- Automations with a stated blast radius. A rule is a stored search plus one fixed action, with no model in the loop. It is created disabled, previews as a dry run, acts on 1 to 200 messages per run (25 by default), never deletes, and every run is on the record.
- Tool scopes. Read, search, folders, drafts, send, schedule, delete, automations and contacts are separate scopes. The tools list only shows what a key is scoped for.
- Clear pricing. Free covers 1 inbox and 150 email actions a month, with the first 7 days uncounted. Paid plans have no monthly action cap under fair use.
- Open source and self-hostable. If you want the code on your own server, you can have it.
What CME has that MCPEmails does not
- A classifier before every cleanup action. 11 kinds of mail kept by default, including mail from people, account security changes, money, orders, travel and official records, and it asks you about mail it can't place. Their docs describe no classifier. It matches mail by search terms and acts on the matches.
- Mailbox-scale sweeps. CME scans 25,000 messages on Free, 250,000 on Pro and 500,000 on Power, and the $19 Sweep scans the newest 750,000 inbox emails and cleans all the mail it offers for cleanup. MCPEmails automations act on at most 200 messages per run.
- Trash only, with no override. MCPEmails moves to Trash by default but its email_delete tool accepts permanent: true to hard-delete on IMAP, Fastmail and Outlook. CME has no permanent-delete argument on any tool.
- 150+ tools instead of 17. Analytics, phishing and header checks, contact tools, export, attachment text extraction and follow-ups, each published with the plan that unlocks it.
- A one-time clean. $19 once to clean a mailbox, with no subscription. MCPEmails has no equivalent.
- Numeric limits per plan. Inboxes, messages per scan, cleanup actions per month, searches and sends per day, all published as numbers.
MCPEmails vs Connect My Email
| Capability | MCPEmails | Connect My Email |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 1 inbox, 150 email actions a month, first 7 days uncounted | 2 inboxes, 25,000-message report-only scan, 5,000 guarded reversible cleanup actions a month |
| Entry paid plan | Personal $9/mo or $86.40/yr, 3 inboxes, no monthly action cap under fair use | Pro $9/mo or $86/yr, 5 inboxes, 250,000 per scan, 50,000 cleanup actions a month, 100 sends a day |
| Next plan | Pro $15/mo or $144/yr, unlimited inboxes | Power $19/mo or $182/yr, 10 inboxes, 500,000 per scan, 150,000 cleanup actions a month, 500 sends a day |
| Team plan | Team $79/mo or $756/yr, members with roles, SSO, audit log | Not offered |
| One-time clean | None | $19 Sweep: scans the newest 750,000 inbox emails and cleans all the mail it offers for cleanup |
| Tools | 17 documented, 23 in the tools list with approval and bulk helpers | 150+ |
| Classifier before cleanup | None | 11 kinds kept by default, asks about mail it can't place |
| Permanent delete | Available with permanent: true on IMAP, Fastmail and Outlook; Gmail is Trash only | Not available. Trash only on every provider |
| Automation | Stored search plus one action, 1 to 200 messages per run, never deletes | Rules, scheduled sends and follow-ups, classifier-guarded, Trash only |
| Send safety | Server-enforced approval hold, idempotency keys | Per-inbox send allowlist enforced in the SMTP client, daily send caps of 0 / 100 / 500 |
| Providers | Gmail, Outlook and Microsoft 365, Fastmail, iCloud, Yahoo, Zoho, Yandex, any IMAP | Gmail (Google verification pending) and Outlook over OAuth, iCloud, Yahoo, Fastmail, any IMAP |
| Source | Open source (AGPL), self-host option | Hosted only, no self-host option |
| Compliance claims | Credentials encrypted at rest, mail fetched live and never stored, EU and US hosting | AES-256-GCM with per-user keys. No SOC 2 yet. Details |
Pricing, plainly
The entry prices are the same. MCPEmails Personal and CME Pro both cost $9 a month, and both discount the year to about $86. CME does not try to undercut that. The question is what the money buys. Personal buys 3 inboxes and unmetered actions under fair use. Pro buys 5 inboxes, scans of 250,000 messages, 50,000 classifier-guarded cleanup actions a month and 100 sends a day. MCPEmails Pro at $15 removes the inbox limit. CME Power at $19 stops at 10 inboxes and raises every other number. If you need a team workspace with roles and SSO, only MCPEmails sells one.
Who should pick which
Pick MCPEmails if
- You are building an agent and want a small, well-specified tool surface.
- Idempotency keys and a server-side send hold are the controls you care about most.
- You want to self-host, or your team needs roles, SSO and an audit log.
- You run more than 10 mailboxes and want one unlimited plan.
Pick Connect My Email if
- The mailbox has years of history and needs cleaning, not just an agent reading it.
- You want a classifier deciding what is safe before any bulk action runs.
- You want a one-time $19 clean with no subscription.
- You want analytics, security checks, contacts and export in the same server.