mailmcp.ai alternative when 500 messages a call is not enough
mailmcp.ai is a careful, well-documented email connector for ChatGPT and Claude, built in Prague and honest about its limits. Connect My Email shares its Trash-only stance and adds what it does not have: a classifier, mailbox-scale sweeps, background automation and OAuth for Gmail. Facts about mailmcp.ai below were read from mailmcp.ai on 2026-10-09.
mailmcp.ai
By Swinging Dogs s.r.o. in Prague. Connects Gmail, Outlook and Microsoft 365, iCloud, Fastmail, Yahoo, Zoho and any IMAP mailbox to ChatGPT, Claude, Cursor and VS Code. Per-mailbox permissions, sending off by default, Trash only, bulk preview then apply, and a published internal audit. Free for 2 mailboxes, hosted subscription from 49 euros a year, one-time licences for your own server.
Connect My Email
A hosted MCP server for the inbox you already use. Gmail (Google verification pending) and Outlook over OAuth, iCloud, Yahoo, Fastmail and any IMAP account. 150+ tools, a classifier in front of every bulk cleanup that keeps 11 kinds of mail by default, scans of up to 500,000 messages, scheduled sends and rules that run on the server, and a $19 one-time Sweep. How CME keeps you safe.
What mailmcp.ai does well
- Permissions per mailbox, read-only by default. Reading is the only capability on from the start. Drafts, sending, flags and folders, and Trash are each switched on separately, and tools a mailbox does not permit are not offered to the assistant at all.
- Sending off by default, allowlisted when on. The assistant writes drafts you send yourself. If you turn sending on, mail goes only to addresses or domains you allow, within an hourly limit.
- No permanent delete, anywhere. Trash is a move to the Trash folder and needs its own permission. The product has no permanent-delete tool, and its home page says so in a struck-through line.
- Bulk preview, then apply, then undo. A bulk action applies only what the preview showed and never deletes. Paid plans can undo a bulk batch for 7 days.
- Protection levels. The server can hide typical one-time codes, sign-in links and password resets from the assistant. New mailboxes start at Standard.
- A published self-audit. Sixteen review passes, findings with severity, what was fixed and in which release, accepted trade-offs with the reason, and a section on residual risks no configuration removes. It is not a third-party test, and the page says that too.
- Passwords encrypted in your browser. The server holds one master key and stores no mail, no index and no password database. Decrypted settings live in memory for at most 15 minutes after your last request.
- Fair pricing and refunds. 2 mailboxes free for good. Hosted subscription about 49 euros a year per person for 10 mailboxes. Personal licence 19 euros once for your own server or Claude Desktop. Unlimited 149 euros for an organisation. Full refund within 14 days of a new purchase.
What CME has that mailmcp.ai does not
- Keep rules before any cleanup. mailmcp.ai's triage sorts into reply, newsletter, lists and automated. CME runs 11 keep rules before anything is offered for cleanup, keeping receipts, travel, account security changes and mail from people, and it asks you about mail it can't place.
- Scale. mailmcp.ai bulk actions take at most 500 messages per call, 50 on Free, and triage looks at the newest 60 per mailbox, at most 200. CME scans 25,000 messages on Free, 250,000 on Pro and 500,000 on Power, and the $19 Sweep scans the newest 750,000 inbox emails and cleans all the mail it offers for cleanup.
- Work that runs when you are not asking. mailmcp.ai works only when your assistant calls it and nothing runs in the background. CME runs scheduled sends, rules, follow-up reminders and digests on the server.
- OAuth for Gmail. mailmcp.ai connects Gmail with an app password. CME connects Gmail and Outlook with OAuth, so your password never passes through CME. Google verification of the Gmail app is still pending.
- Outlook without a 3-mailbox cap. mailmcp.ai allows at most 3 Outlook mailboxes per token. On CME an Outlook inbox counts like any other toward 2, 5 or 10.
- 150+ tools. Analytics, phishing and header checks, contact tools, export, attachment text extraction, scheduled send and follow-ups.
- A one-time clean. $19 once to clean a mailbox. mailmcp.ai sells licences and a subscription, not a clean.
mailmcp.ai vs Connect My Email
| Capability | mailmcp.ai | Connect My Email |
|---|---|---|
| Free | 2 mailboxes, bulk up to 50 messages per call, 10 sends an hour, signature on composed messages | 2 inboxes, 25,000-message report-only scan, 5,000 guarded reversible cleanup actions a month, sends to 10 recipients a day (people you've emailed before) |
| Hosted paid | About 49 euros a year per person, billed yearly, 10 mailboxes with at most 3 Outlook, bulk up to 500 per call, 50 sends an hour, 7-day undo | Pro $9/mo or $86/yr, 5 inboxes, 250,000 per scan, 50,000 cleanup actions a month, 100 sends a day |
| Higher plan | Own server: Personal 19 euros once for 5 mailboxes, Unlimited 149 euros per server | Power $19/mo or $182/yr, 10 inboxes, 500,000 per scan, 150,000 cleanup actions a month, 500 sends a day |
| One-time clean | None | $19 Sweep: scans the newest 750,000 inbox emails and cleans all the mail it offers for cleanup |
| Classifier | None. Header-only triage into reply, newsletter, lists, automated | 11 kinds kept by default, asks about mail it can't place |
| Delete | Trash only, needs the Trash permission, no permanent-delete tool | Trash only, no permanent-delete argument |
| Undo | 7-day undo of bulk batches on paid plans | Your Trash folder; archive and mark-read reversible from any client |
| Sending | Off by default, allowlist of addresses or domains, hourly limit | Per-inbox send allowlist enforced in the SMTP client, daily caps 0 / 100 / 500 |
| Background automation | None. Runs only when the assistant calls it | Scheduled sends, rules, follow-ups, digests |
| Gmail sign-in | App password | OAuth (Google verification pending) |
| Outlook | Microsoft sign-in, at most 3 mailboxes per token | OAuth, counts toward the inbox cap like any other |
| Audit | Published internal audit with findings and accepted trade-offs; not a third-party test | Code-cited safety page; no third-party test yet |
| Operator | Swinging Dogs s.r.o., Prague. Hosted server run by the author, no contractual availability guarantee | Single operator, no SLA published |
Pricing, plainly
mailmcp.ai is the cheaper product and CME does not pretend otherwise. Its hosted plan is about 49 euros a year per person for 10 mailboxes, billed yearly. CME Pro is $86 a year for 5 inboxes, Power is $182 a year for 10, and both can be paid monthly. What you pay CME extra for is a classifier on every cleanup action, scans hundreds of times larger per call, automation that runs on the server, OAuth for Gmail and a far wider tool set. If you need read, search, drafts and tidy archiving across a few mailboxes and nothing more, mailmcp.ai is the better value and I would say so to your face.
Who should pick which
Pick mailmcp.ai if
- You want a connector that works only when you ask and keeps nothing on the server.
- You want to run it yourself, on Vercel, Docker or Claude Desktop, for a one-time fee.
- Your mail is a few mailboxes and the job is reading, drafting and light archiving.
- You want the 7-day undo on bulk changes.
Pick Connect My Email if
- The mailbox holds tens or hundreds of thousands of messages and needs cleaning.
- You want a classifier to keep receipts, travel, account security changes and mail from people before anything runs.
- You want scheduled sends, rules and follow-ups that run while you sleep.
- You want Gmail over OAuth and more than 3 Outlook mailboxes.